Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il est... inutile..., from Croquis Dramatiques, published in Le Charivari, May 23, 1857 by Honoré Daumier

Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il est... inutile..., from Croquis Dramatiques, published in Le Charivari, May 23, 1857

Honoré Daumier · 1857

Scroll

“This humorous lithograph by Honoré Daumier captures a relatable moment of domestic struggle, turning a man's clumsy attempt to reach something high into a comical commentary on human effort.”

ABOUT THIS WORK

In this lithograph, a man in a nightshirt and cap stands precariously on a stool, straining to reach something high above him. His arms are outstretched, his body contorted in an awkward, almost balletic pose, as he balances on the small, wobbly perch. Below him, a woman watches with a mixture of concern and exasperation, her hands clasped in front of her. The scene is set in a modest interior, suggested by the simple furniture and the bare walls. This image, published in the satirical French newspaper Le Charivari, captures a moment of domestic absurdity, a common theme for Daumier. The title, "Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il est... inutile..." (Which proves to us how it is... useless...), hints at the futility of the man's efforts, turning a mundane household task into a humorous commentary on human endeavor.

DETAILS
Artist
Honoré Daumier
Date
1857
Medium
Lithograph; second state of two (Delteil)
Location
The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Dimensions
Sheet: 10 in. × 14 3/16 in. (25.4 × 36 cm)
ART MOVEMENTS
LOOK CLOSER

What to Notice

Five details hide in plain sight. Pick one and we’ll show you exactly where to look.

Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il est... inutile..., from Croquis Dramatiques, published in Le Charivari, May 23, 1857

← → step through · Esc to close
4 details are marked · pick a number
01

Woman in the dark dress

The woman at right center sits upright in a wide, ruffled skirt, her face calm and turned slightly to the side. She stands out from the huddled women beside her.

1 of 4 on the painting
02

Crowded seated women

Look at the huddled group of women in the left foreground, packed close together in heavy shawls and wraps. Their bulk fills much of the lower left of the scene.

2 of 4 on the painting
03

Couple walking away

At upper right, a woman in a pale dress walks with two men through what looks like a passage. They are small and lightly drawn, easy to miss.

3 of 4 on the painting
04

Crayon hatching in skirts

Dense, loose hatching builds the dark skirts at the bottom. The scribbly lines give weight and shadow to the billowing fabric, a typical effect of lithographic crayon.

4 of 4 on the painting
05Whole painting

Crowd versus emptiness

Heavy dark masses crowd the left and bottom, while the right and back open into pale space. The contrast makes the foreground feel jammed.

AUDIO DEEP DIVE

Stand in front of it and listen

The full narration walks you through Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il est... inutile..., from Croquis Dramatiques, published in Le Charivari, May 23, 1857 — the story behind it, the details most visitors miss, and why it matters. Free in the Art Whisper app.

0:00Preview · 0:30Free preview · 0:30 Hear the full story in the app
THE ARTIST
MORE FROM THIS ARTIST

Further Works by Daumier

1 / 2
EXPLORE THE MOVEMENT

More from Naturalism

See the movement →
KEEP EXPLORING

More works to explore

Beyond Daumier and Naturalism: works from the same years.

Hear Ce qui nous prouve comme quoi il…’s storyFree in the Art Whisper app Open