“Stop to see this striking artwork, where two women are locked in a dramatic fight, rendered with a unique blend of watercolor, ink, and chalk over a lithograph, creating a powerful sense of movement and raw emotion.”
A dramatic struggle unfolds in this vibrant watercolor, as two women engage in a fierce physical confrontation. Their forms are rendered with dynamic energy, their limbs intertwined and expressions intense. The artist layered watercolor and pen and ink over a lithograph, creating a rich texture and depth that enhances the sense of movement and tension. Red chalk and graphite add further nuance, highlighting the contours of their bodies and the folds of their garments. This technique, combining printmaking with drawing and painting, gives the scene a unique visual quality, almost like a heightened illustration. The choice of a violent subject, depicted with such raw immediacy, offers a fascinating glimpse into the artistic interests of the late 19th century.
- Artist
- William Hook
- Date
- 1892
- Medium
- Watercolor and pen and black ink, with red chalk and graphite, over lithograph, on cream laid paper, laid down on white wood-pulp laminate board
- Location
- Art Institute of Chicago
- Dimensions
- 50.1 × 34 cm (19 3/4 × 13 7/16 in.)
- Collection
- Prints and Drawings
- Culture
- England
- Credit line
- Gift of Robert Allerton
What to Notice
Five details hide in plain sight. Here’s where to look.

Observe the women's intertwined limbs, conveying the struggle's intensity.
Notice the visible lines of the underlying lithograph beneath the watercolor.
Look closely at the red chalk highlights on their skin and clothing.
See the expressions on their faces, conveying anger and exertion.
1 more detail is waiting.
See all 5 in Art Whisper →Stand in front of it and listen
The full narration walks you through Women Fighting — the story behind it, the details most visitors miss, and why it matters. Free in the Art Whisper app.
William Hook
1829William Hook, born in 1829, is associated with works like 'Alice' and 'A City Park' from the late 19th century.
Further Works by Hook
A City Park
1887 · Art Institute of Chicago
At Mouquin's
1905 · Art Institute of Chicago
Alice
1892 · Art Institute of Chicago
It's a New Age
1992 · Art Institute of Chicago
Garment Hook
Art Institute of Chicago
Large Hook for a Kettle (Jizaigake)
1875 · Art Institute of Chicago
Maine Landscape
1927 · Art Institute of Chicago
Fall Meadow (Sample)
1950 · Art Institute of Chicago
More works to explore
Beyond Hook: works from the same years.
Same era · 1870s–1900s
A Woman Walking in a Garden
Vincent van Gogh · 1887 · Frans Buffa & sons
Same era · 1870s–1900s
A Sunday on La Grande Jatte — 1884
Okada Saburosuke · 1884 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Still Life with Crayfish
Mikhail Larionov · 1900 · Museum Ludwig
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Madame Léon Clapisson
Léon-Victor Dupré · 1883 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Frauenkopf vor Sonnenblumen
Ernst Ludwig Kirchner · 1906 · Museum Frieder Burda
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Paris Street; Rainy Day
Kawabata Gyokushō · 1877 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
At the Moulin Rouge
Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec · 1892 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Fatata Te Moua (At the Foot of a Mountain)
Paul Gauguin · 1892 · Hermitage Museum
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Haymaking at Éragny
Camille Pissarro · 1892 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
Poppy Field (Giverny)
Claude Monet · 1891 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
The Child's Bath
Mary Cassatt · 1893 · Art Institute of Chicago
Same era · 1870s–1900s
The Hands
Edvard Munch · 1893 · Munch Museum
